I like to consider myself the Carrie Bradshaw of the wine world. Not because I am a particularly talented writer, but because I love LA as much as she loves NY AND my expenditures on wine equal hers on Manolo Blahniks. In the 2006 calendar year I spent $13,846.37 on wine. Retail. For some big collectors that’s nothing, I know. But for me, with my modest income, that’s more than I pay annually in rent. And that’s why I’m like Carrie Bradshaw, she couldn’t afford her apartment either.
Inspired by a friend who turned me onto a 1991 Dominus some months back, I proposed to our tasting group that I source a few 1991’s and we compare 18-year-old Napa Cabernet. As my inclinations are almost always old world (I will generally pull an Italian or French wine as my “go to” wine) this tasting might be the one to start to alter my thinking.
These wines were all amazing. They had some things in common from a profile perspective but they were all distinct and delicious. Not a corked or damaged wine in the bunch and a fantastic experience overall.
We tasted the wines blind and none were decanted. The group’s overwhelming favorite was the Insignia. But we decided this might not be fair because the Insignia had 10% Merlot and 10% Cabernet Franc, so not a “true” Cabernet. My blind favorite was the Montelena (along with one other person).
This is the order they ended up being served blind.
1991 Laurel Glen Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley Very good. Fleshy, easy fruit. Good aromatics. Dark red berries and earth.
1991 Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Napa Valley More complex than #1. Higher acid. Some good funk in the nose. Cherries. Mint. Forest floor.
1991 Silver Oak Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley Silky. Tar in the nose. Intense. Gobs of fruit on the palate.
1991 Joseph Phelps Insignia Napa Valley Tomatoes and Twizzlers in the nose. Nice brightness. Rich. Good balance.
1991 Dunn Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley Dusty. Rich red fruit. Bright acidity and a little funk in the finish.
1991 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley Red candied nose. Silky texture. Great balance of intensity and richness. Well done.
Go find some older California wines and give it whirl.